Myth Buster #3: Your Airbnb Competition Looks Like You

Sound Familiar?

Pesky Problem

You think your Airbnb competition is just mom and pop shops like you.

The first time I encountered the concept of an Airbnb megahost, Jay and I weren’t traveling. I was just going over to a friend’s new apartment for dinner. She had recently moved into the city’s old industrial district where large investors were flipping abandoned warehouses into modern lofts. The industrial chic design was on point.

Over dinner, I asked my friend how many of the lofts were occupied so far. I was curious how long it would take our city’s old industrial ghost town to transition to the vibrant neighborhood these investors clearly had in mind. As she estimated her building’s current tenant count, she mentioned offhandedly, “But the management team also put a bunch of the unoccupied units on Airbnb, so there are definitely more people coming in and out of the building than just the tenants.” Boom. My first encounter with an Airbnb megahost.

Let's Try This

Bite-Size Solution

Open your eyes to what your Airbnb competition actually looks like.

Back in the day, the early adopters who put Airbnb on the map were primarily mom-and-pop hosts who had just one unit to list on the platform. But once the concept had been vetted and investors knew that travelers would indeed book short term rentals, the composition of the hosting community began to shift.

As of May 2023, according to AirDNA’s research, only 1 in every 4 Airbnb hosts has just one listing. (This chart from Nerdwallet is very helpful to see the full breakdown.) That means 75% of hosts on the Airbnb platform have more than one listing. And a quarter of those hosts have 21 or more Airbnb listings. These are the Airbnb megahosts, and these investors control a vastly disproportionate percentage of listings on platforms like Airbnb.

So if you are part of the 50% of short term rental hosts who have just 1 to 5 units listed on Airbnb, what does this mean for you?

1) You have to be clear-eyed about who your competition truly is.
Are the statistics above surprising to you? It’s so easy to assume that our personal experience mirrors the majority. As travelers, we tend to be drawn to hosts with fascinating stories behind creating their place. And it’s easy for us to assume that since we cherry pick these types of places, that this represents the typical Airbnb travel experience. The same may be true for you as a host. When you picture the competition, some fuzzy version of your own experience comes to mind. This is why staying up-to-date with the general state of the short term rental industry matters. The reality check might be a little shocking, but a proper understanding of the market will make an enormous difference when it comes to implementing strategies that will actually help you reach your financial goals.

2) You have to build an online Airbnb listing that can actually compete.
Gone are the days when mediocre photography and a sloppy description could keep your place booked. The investors and management companies saturating the Airbnb marketplace have a rinse-and-repeat marketing plan they implement with each listing. And you better believe that plan includes professional photography, good copywriting, intentional search engine optimization, and data-driven marketing strategies. Individual hosts can absolutely do all of these things too! These tactics are all way simpler than they might initially sound. But you have to actually engage with the strategies to stay afloat in this ever-more competitive market.

3) You have to lean into what makes your place unique: you!
So yes, you need to implement some of the same tactics in your online listing as the big management companies in order to compete. But your listing should have one definitively different element that big business can replicate: your personal story. Here’s the good news. The more rentals a host or management company has, the worse their ratings tend to be. Guests like traveling with individual hosts they can visualize and interact with as real people. Which means you, your story, and your personal brand of hospitality will set you apart from the Goliaths on the platform.

5 Minutes

Here's Your First Step

Advertise that you are not an Airbnb megahost.

If you’ve been following along with Big Heart Hosting for a while, you might well remember a post we did several years back asking the question: Is your Airbnb profile blank? It’s time to repose the same question: even if you know you should, have you actually taken the time to thoroughly fill out your own Airbnb profile? Are you sharing your story and your connection to the property with your guests in your online listing? If you haven’t, this is definitely the time to do it.

And if you are not a meghost, shout it from the rooftops! This is how you can stand out. This is your secret sauce. You represent the original Airbnb that so many travelers are searching for when they pull out their phone and start looking for their next travel destination. Don’t hide it. Flaunt it. Your bank account will thank you.

related content

more posts like this

get social

save or share this post

The number one question we hear from hosts is “What am I forgetting to put in my Airbnb?” This collection is the definitive answer to that question. In our signature product, we go room-by-room, step-by-step until your Airbnb is perfectly appointed and ready to impress. Bye-bye blindspots and hello happy guests!

free checklist!

Even the best hosts can forget a thing or two

Luckily all 15 of these common mistakes are super easy to fix. Grab your copy of the checklist below and dive on in!

Erin & Jay
WELCOME TO

big heart hosting

we help hosts thrive

You’re an ambitious Airbnb host with a big heart. But on some days, hosting isn’t exactly what you had imagined. Maybe it’s overwhelming. Or isolating. Or just not making the kind of money you had envisioned. At Big Heart Hosting, we’re on a mission to help hosts like you thrive, not just get by. We create step-by-step resources that bring together the best hosting strategies from around the world. We’ll give you the knowledge and community you need to create the joyful, prosperous Airbnb you deserve.

Erin & Jay

Airbnb photos of bedroom
Interior Design

The Bed Is Dusty

The extra bedroom has a dusty bed. We’ve seen this. A lot. Like way more than you’d expect. Incredible Airbnbs that have a spotless master

Read More »

Download our most popular free hosting resource now!

THE AIRBNB BEGINNER CHECKLIST BUNDLE
Download our most popular free resource now!

free bundle!

5 Checklists Every Airbnb Hosts Needs

JUST ENTER YOUR EMAIL BELOW & WE'LL SEND THE AIRBNB BEGINNER CHECKLIST BUNDLE YOUR WAY!