The Suggestion Box Paradox

Sound Familiar?

Pesky Problem

You’re worried a suggestion box primes guests to be critical.

You’ve thought about setting out a suggestion box in your Airbnb before, but each time you consider it, you get uneasy. You wonder: “Doesn’t that just prompt guests to start critiquing the space? Do I really want to ask my guests to focus on negative things while they’re visiting? Plus can’t they just say this stuff in the app when they leave a review.” We can completely understand these doubts. And after all the work you’ve invested in your Airbnb, setting up an avenue for potential criticism can feel particularly disheartening.

Let's Try This

Bite-Size Solution

Flip the script. Guests love an invitation to share their thoughts.

But here’s the catch. When the vast majority of guests see a suggestion box, it doesn’t make them shift gears into a negative critic. Paradoxically, it actually has the opposite effect. It primes folks with rose-colored glasses from the moment they see it. All humans love to be genuinely asked: “What do you think?”

By setting out a suggestion box, you demonstrate to your guests that you truly care about making an amazing experience for them. You’re saying: “I see you and your perspective is valuable.” Plus you’re offering an old-school, analog opportunity to connect, which feels much more human than a templatized prompt from a tech giant asking for more feedback. And here’s the funny thing: most guests won’t leave any suggestions at all. But! Every single one of your guests will appreciate the fact that you asked. That’s the magic: the invitation, the recognition, the humility. You know: the humanness of this whole Airbnb endeavor.

5 Minutes

Here's Your First Step

Set out a friendly suggestion box in the entryway.

Ready to create those rose-colored glasses? This will just take you a few minutes to prepare. Pick a small container or bowl that can serve as your suggestion box. Label it and set it out along with a little stack of papers and a few pens. We’d recommend putting it as close to the entryway as possible so you impress guests as soon as they arrive. Finally, add a personal note from you with instructions. This can be as simple as a sticky note that says something like: “We’re always looking to improve our Airbnb! Got any ideas? We’d love to hear your thoughts. Just leave us a note here. Thank you!”

get social

save or share this post

The number one question we hear from hosts is “What am I forgetting to put in my Airbnb?” This collection is the definitive answer to that question. In our signature product, we go room-by-room, step-by-step until your Airbnb is perfectly appointed and ready to impress. Bye-bye blindspots and hello happy guests!

free checklist!

Even the best hosts can forget a thing or two

Luckily all 15 of these common mistakes are super easy to fix. Grab your copy of the checklist below and dive on in!

Erin & Jay
WELCOME TO

big heart hosting

we help hosts thrive

You’re an ambitious Airbnb host with a big heart. But on some days, hosting isn’t exactly what you had imagined. Maybe it’s overwhelming. Or isolating. Or just not making the kind of money you had envisioned. At Big Heart Hosting, we’re on a mission to help hosts like you thrive, not just get by. We create step-by-step resources that bring together the best hosting strategies from around the world. We’ll give you the knowledge and community you need to create the joyful, prosperous Airbnb you deserve.

Erin & Jay

lightbulbs with feathered wings
Featured Stay

The Modern Hayloft

This Airbnb was simply sensational. The second stop on our Airbnb honeymoon, the Modern Hayloft in Cotswolds was everything the pictures promised and more. This

Read More »

Download our most popular free hosting resource now!

THE AIRBNB BEGINNER CHECKLIST BUNDLE
Download our most popular free resource now!

free bundle!

5 Checklists Every Airbnb Hosts Needs

JUST ENTER YOUR EMAIL BELOW & WE'LL SEND THE AIRBNB BEGINNER CHECKLIST BUNDLE YOUR WAY!